May 12, 2014

How To Choose a Paint Color: 10 Tips To Help You Decide

One of the most frequently asked questions I get is about choosing a paint color. I'm no expert, but after painting our entire house 2+ times and experimenting with tons of different paint colors, I've definitely learned a thing or two. So, today I'm going to share some of our newly painted rooms, and share my 10 tips for choosing a color.
And then probably mix in some random nonsense. Because that's how we do.

For the past four years, I've been obsessed with paint. It's not normal. I know that. It started when I painted the guest bedroom for the first time. And then I went on a four year paint binge. I painted every room in our house, some rooms up to three times each. I would usually start out with a horrible color (that always seemed great at the time) and then slowly work my way towards a color that I liked. All of this painting took up a lot of my time, but despite the occasional tears of exhaustion, it was fun for me. Kinda like a hobby.
There's something about your first house that makes you do irrational things. 
Like manual labor.

But, through the years of trial and error, I've really learned a lot about choosing a paint color. I still occasionally mess stuff up, but for the most part, I've figured out a paint-choosing-process that works pretty well. So, before I share some of our newly painted rooms, let's talk about my process for choosing a paint color. 

1. Look at what you're pinning.
Choosing a paint color can be really overwhelmingIf you're like me and pin a lot, you can really get some useful information by looking through some of your recent pins.

  For example, when I look through my own boards (like this one or this one), I notice that the majority of the rooms I've pinned over the past year have had white walls. So, when it came time to choose a new paint color for the main level of our home, I decided I should go where I've never gone before: white paint. I had no idea if white would look good in our house, but it gave me a starting point.
Speaking of Pinterest, here's an amazing Pinterest board I follow with tons of suggestions for great paint colors. 

2. Take cues from your decor.
Look for colors that complement the colors of your furniture, rugs, flooring, and fabrics, but make sure not to overwhelm the room. If you have a really bold rug (like I do in the master bedroom), you probably don't want to paint the walls in equally strong hues. Let the rug be the focal point, and keep the walls a soothing neutral. If you do decide to paint the walls a bold color, it usually helps to make the walls the focal point, and keep the decor fairly simple. Another thing to keep in mind is that dark colors create a lot of warmth, but can also make a small space feel even smaller. Light colors tend to open up a space and make it feel larger than it is.  
In my experience, I need to either go white or go with the darkest paint color on the paint strip. I've done the in between colors and it rarely works out for me. So far, white walls and very saturated neutrals tend to be my faves.

3. Use neutrals for versatility.

Neutrals are simple and classic, and work with just about anything. By keeping the paint neutral, you can play around with the other items in the room, like art, fabric, and rugs. One of my favorite neutrals is Behr Wheat Bread. It's a great greige and I've been happy with our master bedroom ever since I painted it. The paint color works with just about anything, and you guys know how many times I've changed that room.

4. Use Paint chips.
There's an abnormal amount of paint colors out there. 
Don't let it overwhelm you.

 If you try to pick out a paint color AT the store (a mistake I've made at least 5 times), you'll get overwhelmed and probably end up with something you aren't 100% happy with. 
So, bring the paint chips home first.
I know it's a pain, but it's worth the extra effort. 
This time around, I went the extra mile. I had 3 full months to choose a color AND I was painting a massive area. Plus, I had zero desire to recreate the stain debacle with paint.
So, I went to Home Depot, Lowes, ACE, and Sherwin Williams, and brought home an illegal amount of paint chips from each one. I'm sure you remember seeing paint chips littered throughout the renovation posts.
Like my own little version of Where's Waldo.

5. Understand color undertones.
Once you've brought home your paint chips, you'll need to narrow them down, and understanding color undertones can be really helpful in this process.

 The best way to figure out the true color tint is to look at the darkest color on the strip, or to hold the color next to something that's true white (like a piece of white paper). Once you've figured out the undertone, it's a lot easier to narrow down your choices.
For example, in the above picture, look at the 'Blue' paint strip. One of the colors I was contemplating was SW Extra White. In the store it looked white. 
In my 1970's house, kinda Smurfy.

6. Online Research
It's not a good idea to go by what a paint color looks like online, but a little online research can definitely help you find some colors worth testing out. I found about 10 different paint names online that I wanted to try, and then brought those paint chips home (along with 800 other ones I grabbed while at the store). After staring at them for awhile, I eventually narrowed down my favorites to Benjamin Moore Simply White, White Dove, Chantilly Lace, and Titanium.

7. Get Samples
After narrowing down my choices, I brought home some paint samples. This is a crucial part of my narrowing down process, as it allows me to see what the paint will actually look like in my home. The sample sizes are usually about $2 and worth every penny.
Benjamin Moore offers tiny pre-mixed samples, but they didn't have any of the colors available where I went. So, instead, I took the paint chips to Home Depot and had them color match the paint. They have giant sample sizes there, and can color match anything (including fabric), and most of the time if it's a brand name paint, they can just pull up the color formula on the computer and mix it without even needing a paint chip. 
It's awesome.

8. Paint swatches on the wall.
Once I've got my paint samples, I usually just find a wall and paint giant swatches on them. It's really helpful for me to see how the actual paint looks on my actual walls, and I don't worry about making a mess since I'm going to be painting over it anyways.
If you are worried about the mess, you can paint poster board and then tape it to your walls. 
Or just tell your husband you're painting a mural in his honor. 
 Or I might just be living in a vacuum where Jesse would believe me if I said that.
 Either way, options.

Funny story: The living room was already painted when we moved in four year ago, and I had no idea what color it was. And then I tested out White Dove on these walls and realized our entire main area was White Dove. In all of the online pictures of White Dove, it looks white, but, in our house, it looks yellow. I also figured out that Titanium was just too dark for this area of the house (although very similar to my master bedroom color, Wheat Bread). 
And this is why you paint swatches.

9. Look at the paint in different light.
Paint can look really different during different times of the day based on the lighting in your house. As a general rule, natural light shows the paint's truest color, incandescent light brings out warm tones and yellows, and fluorescent light casts a sharp blue tone.
I was really going back and forth between Simply White and Chantilly Lace for quite some time, but ultimately decided to go with Simply White. The Chantilly Lace started looking really blue in the mornings and at night (when we don't get a lot of natural light in the front of the house), and Simply White stayed a really beautiful, neutral white all day long. 
It was exactly what I was looking for.

10. Listen to reason (something I rarely do).
 I've painted multiple rooms with a color I chose while standing in the Home Depot paint aisle. And then consequently hating the results. Had I read this post four years ago, I would have totally ignored it. 
I learn things the hard way. 
It's my nature. 

Much to my dismay, taking the thorough approach actually pays off. I was forced to spend 3 months looking at paint chips (because of the neverending floor situation), and as a result, I ended up being so happy with my paint color choice that I never ever want to change it. 
For the first time ever.
I barely know how to handle this new emotion. 

So, let's just look at the house already.
A quick reminder, here's what the kitchen looked like after we first knocked down the wall and ripped up the tile. 

And now today. We still have to install trim (underway now!!), but after painting over the chalkboard wall (I have a plan for that little wall that doesn't involve chalk.), and now with the new white paint, the kitchen feels so much bigger. 
I'm so excited.

And now, here's a reminder of what the living room looked like after we ripped up the carpet. I was totally over the accent wall, and couldn't wait to see what this space would look like with new floors and fresh paint.

And now today.
Just imagine what it will look like with new trim and furniture.
Oh, and my sworn enemies...those dead-bug-hoarding lights? Their days are numbered. Jesse is installing the new ones for me sometime this week. 
It should be an interesting climb. I'll report back.

Plus, my paint sprayer finally arrived today, so I should be able to begin painting my beloved stair rail this week. 
I feel a furnished home on the horizon....
a sentence I've been longing to say for 13 weeks.

And that, ya'll, is pretty much all for today. Hopefully this helps you with your next paint-choosing adventure. Just know that whether you want to paint your walls red, or purple, or gray, or white, you should do exactly that. Do what makes you happy, make it your own, and if you get frazzled by the 8 million red paint chips, spend some time narrowing it down before taking the purchase plunge. 
I imagine that last paragraph to be like the last few minutes of Full House or Family Matters where they play saxaphone music and summarize the moral of the story.

I'll be back later this week to answer another one of your FAQS: how to paint a room (like what supplies to buy, how to actually do it, what paint to get, etc.). 
The house is finally getting put back together and I'm starting to actually feel kinda normal. I do laundry again, cook food in an oven, paint my nails, and DVR things. 
I know I've been a little here and there over the past few months, and you guys have been so amazing with your support and encouragement. I've always been a blogger who finishes a project and THEN tells you about it, so I really had no idea what to expect when I started ripping up my house and blogging about my mess over a 3 month period. I just can't thank you enough for making it such a fun experience for me. 
So, thanks for sticking around. 
I never expected it, and I'm grateful for it.

Also, sidenote #15:  Happy belated Mother's Day to all the mamas out there. You make the world a happy place. Jesse and I celebrated my sweet Mama (Jeannie) over brunch yesterday. There were Mimosas, bacon, and sunshine. 
It was a happy occasion. 

Love ya'll!
Til next time!
 To read the other posts in the renovation series, go here:
Or to see a list of previous paint colors I've used in our home, go here.

That's all for today! 'Til next time!
Follow my blog with
bloglovin' photo BlogLovin_zps5407d9e3.jpg
pinterest facebook instagram twitter Image Map

Subscribe to LiveLoveDIY with email!
Enter your email address:



  1. I look forward to every single post you write! I started following your blog to find out information on flipping furniture (and hobby I am now OBSESSED with) and my husband and I are in the process of house hunting, (oh the joys!) and your blogs are literally becoming my Bible. Thank you for sharing the good, the bad, the pretty and the not so successful with your readers! I've had a few flops with projects here and there and it can be upsetting to your pride and your project but it's always encouraging to read your success stories and see the process. Keep on keeping on and I can't wait to see how everything turns out for you!


    1. Thanks so much Dawn! That's so amazing! Love having you as a reader! xo

  2. Such great tips. My biggest thing is to always use the color undertones for the overall feel.

  3. oh my living room is Behr Wheat Bread but it looks SO DIFFERENT then it does in your house that I never noticed they were the same. I absolutely love the color, but it's quite a bit darker in my house. :)

    1. I totally believe it! I've painted the same color in multiple rooms and had it look completely different! There are so many factors that can change the way it looks...mostly lighting!

  4. I think watching the trend in paint colors is so amusing....10 or so years ago I feel like people couldn't wait to cover up the white walls with bright bold colors everywhere. But now I feel like it's making a strong push back towards neutrals and whites. I love it. I can't believe how much it opened up your kitchen!

    WOOT WOOT for loving your paint color first time around!

  5. This past January we gave our master bathroom a farmhouse look, and painted it all in Simply White, with the bead board and trims in the same color, only in semi-gloss. It is a truly beautiful white, with just enough warmth to not be too stark. I have wanted to paint the rest of the house in the same color ever since. I'm glad you decided on this color. I also want to let you know how much I appreciate your past painting advice. Last year we painted our getaway home in your "favorite greige" color, written about in one of your previous posts, and have never regretted it. We also painted the kitchen cabinets and trim work up there in the whites that you had also then recommended. I'm so glad to see how nice your house is coming along. Sue

  6. Virginia this is very helpful thank you so much

  7. It is like Christmas when you post a home update!!! I can't wait to see the rest - preachin' to the choir, huh?

  8. As an interior decorator let me just say two things: One, all your tips for choosing paint colors are spot on Virginia! and Two, I LOVEs me my white or light neutral rooms :-) I have a lot of them in my house too :-) The tip about NOT picking paint in the store is one of the most important ones. The store staff will tell you things like "This color is a good seller/really popular....." Do NOT listen to them! They may very well sell a lot of that color but they have no idea if it's right in your home because unless they've been there at varying times of the day to see e.v.e.r.y.t.h.i.n.g (carpeting, furniture, artwork, window coverings, lighting conditions, etc.) they cannot really be of much help to you on choosing paint colors. However, they are knowledgeable (usually) on choosing the right paint formulation for your project. I cannot tell you how many times I've been called to do paint consults after the client has chosen a paint color in the store. It's a hard 'fix it' because they don't like what they have and yet they often don't want to have to paint again right away. So listen to Virginia. She's got it all figured out :-) Thanks Virginia. You're the best!

  9. Thanks Virginia, your post couldn't have come at a better time (ok, maybe two days earlier, ha ha!). I just pained my living room yellow yesterday. And it's BRIGHT. Do paint colors grow on you after a while, or do you think if I don't like it, scrap it and bite the bullet and repaint? I mean, I kinda like it, just not sure yet...

  10. I so agree with you, take the chips home and tape them to your wall! They look so different sometimes. have a quirk that I like all the colors of my house to match. Not be the same, but I like a flow and I don't want it to stop at one room and be WHOA. My last house had a couch that was a tan/gold color and had several other colors in the design. I painted the main large room the tan/gold and all the other rooms a color from the couch. That was the best job I ever did picking colors. I also like it if a house is painted all light colors or all medium colors, it really flows. You really have good tips.

  11. Thank you SO much for this post Virginia!! You have no idea how helpful this is! I have had two major paint mistakes, I was going for light pink and ended up painting my daughters room hot pink, and going for a cream and painted my bedroom yellow! My husband and I are getting ready to fix those and also paint the rest of the house a nice light beige or gray beige and I told him all about this post and we have agreed to follow your advice and take our time choosing our next colors!! I think in the long run we will be so happy we took the extra time like you did to find the perfect color, we have always made our choice at the store and I vow to never do that again! LOL :) :)

  12. A great post. Thanks for these helpful tips (and written with such disarming humor). Your renovation is looking fabulous!

  13. I love reading your blog. You give me so many tips and ideas. Keep up the good work.

  14. Recently underwent a painting project and found that actually picking the paint color was the hardest step in the process. We went through about $50 in samples (go to Home Depot $3, not Sherwin Williams $7) and were still lost until my girlfriend found the "paint visualizer" tool on the Behr website. This site was extremely helpful in allowing us to visualize how different colors would look in rooms, and find other colors in that palette. I highly recommend using that site!

  15. This is such good advice. I have spent the same last 4 years doing the same thing. My husband and kids think I am crazy... which is mostly true. Yesterday I spray painted the toaster (which was just me testing out the spray paint on an appliance so I could paint my kitchenaid mixer red with a little experience under my belt.) and I think I crossed the line for the last time. My hubby nearly split a gasket! I bought a new toaster today. The mixer looks great though! The guys at the hardware store in our small town call me the "paint lady". It's embarrassing. But, this week I finished painting the last room in our house again (I have also painted each room at least twice. ) and it is finally what I wished it was when we moved in. I agree with all your tips. And in answer to SGS' s question, none of my old paint choices grew on me. If you don't love it now it may bug you forever! I would paint again even if your hubby thinks you are nutters!!!

  16. Hello! I have nominated you for the Versatile Blogger Award

  17. What paint sprayer did you buy? I am looking for one myself!

  18. I never thought about the color undertones before and that makes a big difference. I am going to use your DIY tips when I go to choose my next paint color. You have also inspired me to buy and paint a used dresser for storage in my office/craft room.

  19. I just LOVE reading your blog!! You're house looks amazing and I think you've done a beautiful job. I find myself constantly checking my email, looking for the latest update.
    You've been such an inspiration with the decorating of my new home. Thank you, thank you, thank you for continuing to share with us all of your projects!

    PS... The hubby is taking me to Lowes tonight to pick up some paint supplies, so I can finish up projects started. Your posts couldn't have come at better time! It's gonna be a fun holiday weekend filled with lots of painting!!

  20. I loved your post. I just spent over a month...and 100 paint chips picking a color. I went through the exact processes you did... and they just finished the second coat of Simply White on my walls. Of course.. I found your post today and find it hilarious that we both narrowed it down to Simply White. We don't have floors yet but I am very optimistic that once the floors (walnut hardwood) are in, I will love the end result. Thank you for the post.

  21. Love your wood floors - the color is exactly what I'm looking for, as we are updating our new/old home, too. Can you please share the details on type, color, brand, etc.? It would help so much, thank you!

  22. Love your white comforter bedroom set with the floral pillows, where is the comforter set from?!?

  23. I'm about to tackle a fixer upper that needs a MAJOR paint overhaul. Once I decided on a whilte, it's going in floor to ceiling. Any tips on picking a paint and/or finish that's versatile enough for all?

  24. Love you pictures. I'm looking at a similar floor. Can you share details about it? And also planning to do white walls. Your post was perfect timing for me!

  25. Did you use Simply White for your kitchen cabinets?


Thanks so much for leaving a comment!! I do the hammer dance every time I read one.

Quick and Easy LiveLoveDIY Projects

Mod Podge Hangers Photo Wall Ideas Sequin Art Chalkboard Cabinets Gold Leaf Art Stacked Log Tutorial